Working on RSS Bandit is my hobby and sometimes I retreat to it when I need to unwind from the details of work or just need a distraction. This morning was one of such moments. I decided to look into the issue raised in the thread from our forums entitled MSN Spaces RSS Feeds Issues - More Info where some of our users complained about a cookie parsing error when subscribed to feeds from MSN Spaces.

Before I explain what the problem is, I'd like to show an example of what an HTTP cookie header looks like from the Wikipedia entry for HTTP cookie

Set-Cookie: RMID=732423sdfs73242; expires=Fri, 31-Dec-2010 23:59:59 GMT; path=/;

Note the use of a semicolon as a delimiter for separating cookies. So it turned out that the error was in the following highlighted line of code

if (cookieHeaders.Length > 0) {
container.SetCookies(url, cookieHeaders.Replace(";", ","));

You'll note that we replace the semicolon delimiters with commas. Why would we do such a strange thing when the example above shows that cookies can contain commas? It's because the CookieContainer.SetCookies method in the .NET Framework requires the delimiters to be commas. WTF ?

This seems so fundamentally broken I feel that I must be mistaken. I've tried searching for possible solutions to the problem online but I couldn't find anyone else who has had this problem. Am I using the API incorrectly? Am I supposed to parse the cookie by hand before feeding it to the method? If so, why would anyone design the API in such a brain damaged manner?


I was having more fun drafting my specs for work.

Update: Mike Dimmick has pointed out in a comment below that my understanding of cookie syntax is incorrect. The cookie shown in the Wikipedia example is one cookie not four as I thought. It looks like simply grabbing sample code from blogs may not have been a good idea.:) This means that I may have been getting malformed cookies when fetching the MSN Spaces RSS feeds after all. Now if only I can repro the problem...